How To Toast English Muffin In An Air Fryer + Tips on Reheating

Looking for a simple and fast way to toast your English muffins? Look no further!

Toasting English muffins using an air fryer is a quick and easy solution, taking only 5 minutes from start to finish. With the perfect texture and flavor, you can enjoy your favorite breakfast in no time.

Let’s explore how to toast English muffin in an air fryer perfectly.


How To Toast English Muffin In An Air Fryer?

Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to toast English muffin in an air fryer;

1. Preheat the Air Fryer:

Turn on your air fryer and set it to 375F. Let it preheat for 3-5 minutes.

This will ensure that the air fryer is hot enough to properly cook the English muffin while still maintaining its fluffy texture. 

2. Fork Split the English Muffin:

Using a fork, carefully separate the two sides of the muffin, cutting it in half and leaving a textured inside that’s great for spreads and butter.

This step ensures that there is enough surface area for even cooking while still keeping some of its shapes intact. 

3. Toast the English muffin:

Place the split English muffin halves at the bottom of the air fryer basket and set the timer for 5 minutes.

Depending on how dark you enjoy your toast, leave it in anywhere from 2 minutes to 8 minutes using the chart below. 

2 mins Lightly Crisped
4 minsGolden Brown
6 minsMedium Brown
8 mins Dark Brown/Burnt Edges

Remove the toasted English muffins with tongs and spread them with your favorite butter, jam, or jelly while warm. Enjoy!  

How Long Does it Take to Toast an English Muffin?

It takes approximately 5 minutes to toast an English muffin in the air fryer using preheated 375F.

The timing depends on how dark you like it, as outlined in the table above.

What Do You Eat with English Muffins?

Let’s explore some of the best toppings and fillings to make your morning meal even more enjoyable. 

1. Jam and Butter 

This classic combination takes only minutes to prepare but is sure to delight your taste buds. Spread your favorite jam over one-half of the muffin, top with butter, and assemble!

This combo gives you just enough sweetness to start off your day.

For extra flavor, add a sprinkle of cinnamon or nutmeg. 

2. Honey and Cream Cheese 

This combo is perfect for those who prefer something on the sweeter side. Spread cream cheese on one half of the muffin, drizzle with honey, and assemble!

You can also stir together honey and cream cheese for a smooth spread before topping off your muffin.

If you want an extra special treat, add fresh fruit like strawberries or blueberries for added texture and flavor.  

3. Eggs and Bacon 

If you’re looking for something savory, this pairing is sure to hit the spot! Fry up some bacon (or cook it in the oven) while you toast your English muffin halves.

Assemble with eggs (scrambled, poached, fried—the options are endless!) and top with freshly cracked pepper for some extra zing! If desired, add shredded cheese on top for an extra cheesy treat. 

Do You Toast English Muffins Whole?

Yes, you can toast an English muffin whole in the air fryer.

To do so, simply place the muffin in the air fryer basket and set the timer for 3-5 minutes.

english muffin in an air fryer - how to toast an english muffin in an air fryer

Depending on how dark you like your toast, leave it for anywhere from 2-8 minutes using the chart above. 

Do You Cut an English Muffin Before Toasting?

It’s best to fork-split the English muffin before toasting if you want even cooking and a fluffy texture.

Simply use a fork to cut through the sides of the muffin, leaving it with its shape intact.

This will ensure that there is enough surface area for the air fryer to properly cook the inside while keeping some of its shapes.

Why Air Fryer Is The Best To Toast an English Muffin?

Let’s take a look at why air fryer Is the best to toast an english muffin:

1. Time Efficiency 

One of the main benefits of using an air fryer to toast English muffins is its time efficiency.

Rather than waiting several minutes for your toaster oven or conventional oven to heat up, you can simply pop your English muffin into the air fryer basket and it will be ready in just a few minutes’ time.

This makes it much easier and faster to get your meals prepped and ready! 

2. Healthier Option 

Another benefit of using an air fryer to toast English muffins is that it’s much healthier than other methods.

By cutting out all the oil and fat associated with deep frying, you are able to enjoy delicious food without all of the added calories.

With an air fryer, you can enjoy your favorite snacks without having to worry about all of those unhealthy fats! 

3. Reduced Mess 

Finally, using an air fryer means you don’t have to worry about all the mess usually associated with deep frying food.

Since there’s no need for any messy oil or grease, you don’t have to worry about cleaning up after each use.

Plus, since most models are designed for easy cleanup, you won’t have any trouble getting your air fryer back into shape after each use!  

How To Reheat an English Muffin?

If you want to reheat an English muffin in your air fryer simply place it in there for 30-60 seconds at 375F until warmed through.

This will help bring back some of its crunchy texture without burning it like it would if it was put directly into a preheated oven or traditional oven set at 350F or higher temperatures.  

Tips to Perfectly Toast English Muffins in an Air Fryer:

We’ll give you all the tips and tricks you need for the perfect English muffin toast every time. 

  • The most important thing when it comes to toasting English muffins in an air fryer is not cutting the English muffin with a knife. Cutting with a knife will make the inside flat and not as textured. Use a fork instead, it works perfectly!
  • Keep an eye on them so they don’t burn! It’s important that you do not overcrowd your air fryer or Ninja Foodi as this will result in unevenly toasted English muffins. If you are cooking for a large group, cook your English muffins in batches. 
  • If you don’t have an air fryer, no worries! You can use your oven set to broil on high for about 45 seconds per side—just keep a close eye on them so they don’t burn!
  • When done correctly, your perfectly-toasted English muffins should be light and fluffy on the inside and golden brown on the outside. 


Toasting an English muffin in an air fryer is not only fast but also results in perfectly crisp yet fluffy bread every time.

Plus, with minimal effort involved, you can have delicious toast ready any morning of the week!

Whether you prefer lightly crisped or dark browned edges, this simple method will give you plenty of options when it comes to creating tasty breakfasts quickly and easily.

Don’t forget that if need be, reheating already-toasted English muffins can be done easily by placing them in the air fryer set at 375F for 30-60 seconds until warmed through.

There are so many delicious ways to enjoy an English muffin! Whether you’re looking for something sweet or savory—or both—you can find something that will tantalize your taste buds with this classic breakfast item.

Now that we’ve shared our secrets with you, go forth and make an amazing toast!

Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of, Inc, or its affiliates.

Kapnos Taverna Author - Small
About the author

Natalie is a food enthusiast who spends all of her time trying out new recipes, testing out new appliances, and making her kitchen as awesome as possible. She is a professional writer and blogs here about her love of food & kitchen.

Leave a Comment