Take Air Fryer S’Mores to the Next Level Through These Tips

S’mores are a staple of summertime treats, and they’re even better when you use an air fryer to make them!

But if you’re looking for something new and exciting to add to your air fryer s’mores, here are some delicious variations that will make your taste buds go wild. 


How to Make Air Fryer S’Mores?

Read on to learn how to make air fryer s’mores. 

1. Preheat Your Air Fryer 

Before you get started, preheat your air fryer to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. This will give your s’mores plenty of time to melt while they cook.

You should also lightly grease the basket of the air fryer with cooking spray or oil so that your s’mores don’t stick when you remove them from the basket. 

2. Assemble Your S’mores 

Now it’s time to assemble your s’mores!

  • Take 2 graham crackers and place 1 square of chocolate on each one.
  • Place one marshmallow between the two pieces of chocolate and top with another graham cracker.
  • Repeat until you have as many s’mores as desired (4 is a good number for an average-sized air fryer). 

3. Cook Your S’mores 

  • Carefully place your assembled s’mores in the preheated air fryer basket and close the lid.
  • Cook for 4-5 minutes until the marshmallow is melted and golden brown, flipping halfway through cooking if desired for more even melting.
  • Use a pair of tongs or oven mitts to carefully remove from the basket and enjoy immediately!  

Do I Need to Break the Marshmallows in Half to Make Air Fryer S’Mores?

No, you do not need to break the marshmallows in half.

The air fryer will heat up enough that the marshmallow will expand and melt without having to be broken beforehand.

However, if you are using jumbo or extra-large marshmallows, it may be a good idea to cut them into smaller pieces before assembling the s’mores.

Air Fryer S’Mores

This will help them melt more evenly in the air fryer and make sure they fit nicely on the graham crackers. Enjoy!

What Substitutions Can I Use for S’Mores to Make Air Fryer S’Mores?

Let’s take a look at some tasty options! 

1. Marshmallow Substitutions 

If you don’t have marshmallows on hand or are looking for a healthier alternative, there are several options.

Marshmallow fluff is a great substitute as it has the same light and fluffy texture that regular marshmallows do. If you’re looking for something with a bit more substance, try using banana slices instead.

They aren’t as sweet as marshmallows but still provide that gooey texture that makes s’mores so delicious. 

2. Chocolate Substitutions 

Milk chocolate is the classic choice for s’mores but it isn’t the only option out there.

For something a bit different, try using dark chocolate instead. It has a bolder flavor and won’t be as sweet as milk chocolate so if you’re looking for something with more depth this could be a perfect choice!

You can also use nut butter spread in place of chocolate chips or bars; just spread it over one side of the graham cracker before adding your marshmallow or banana slice. 

3. Graham Cracker Substitutions 

If you don’t have graham crackers on hand, there are plenty of other crunchy substitutes that will work just as well.

Try using digestive biscuits or gingersnap cookies in place of graham crackers – they both give off that delicious crunch and pair very nicely with either marshmallow fluff or banana slices!

Or if you’re feeling adventurous, why not try making your own homemade graham crackers with some almond flour and honey? The possibilities are endless!  

Do I Need to Use Foil or Parchment Paper When Making Air Fryer S’Mores?

No, you do not need to use foil or parchment paper when making air fryer s’mores.

The food won’t stick to the basket and they’re easy enough to lift out with tongs once they’re done cooking.

You can also lightly grease the basket ahead of time if desired for extra non-stickiness. Enjoy!​​

1. Get Creative With the Chocolate 

One way to make your s’mores more interesting is to play around with the chocolate.

Hershey’s chocolate is a classic, but you could also try dark chocolate, white chocolate, or even squares of cookies and cream chocolate!

For even more flavor, swap out the plain chocolate squares for caramel-filled chocolates, peanut butter cups, or peppermint patties. The possibilities are endless! 

2. Switch Up the Crackers 

Instead of plain graham crackers, you could also try chocolate graham crackers.

Or get a little crazy by replacing them with your favorite cookie—a chewy oatmeal raisin cookie or a crunchy shortbread cookie would both be delicious! 

Or if you’re feeling adventurous, why not mix it up and have one side of your s’more on a graham cracker while the other is on a cookie? 

3. Get Creative With the Marshmallow 

And lastly, don’t forget about the marshmallow! Instead of using traditional marshmallows in your s’mores, why not use flavored marshmallows like strawberries or bananas?

You can also upgrade from regular-sized marshmallows to jumbo ones for an extra special treat.

If you really want to take things up a notch, try cutting shapes into your marshmallows using small metal cutters before air frying them—you can do stars or hearts for an extra special touch.  

Can You Store Leftover Air Fryer S’Mores?

Yes, you can store leftover air fryer s’mores in an airtight container in the fridge for up to four days. They will stay fresh and delicious as long as they are stored properly!

Enjoy your leftovers with a warm cup of cocoa or simply enjoy them as-is – either way, your taste buds will be happy.

What Chocolate Is Best for Air Fryer S’mores?

Read on to learn what chocolate is best for air fryer s’mores and how to get the best results. 

1. Milk Chocolate vs Dark Chocolate 

The debate between milk chocolate and dark chocolate has been raging for years, but when it comes to air fryer s’mores, there is a clear winner—milk chocolate.

The creamy sweetness of milk chocolate pairs perfectly with the crunchy graham crackers and melted marshmallows.

Plus, it melts faster than dark chocolate, which makes it ideal for air fryer s’mores. 

4. Which Brand Is Best? 

When it comes to choosing the right brand of milk chocolate, there are many great options available.

Many people swear by Hershey’s Milk Chocolate bars because they have just the right balance of sweetness and creaminess that works perfectly in an air fryer s’more.

Others prefer Cadbury Dairy Milk bars because they melt faster than other brands and have a richer flavor that really stands out in an air fryer s’more.

Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference so experiment with different brands until you find your favorite! 

5. Variations on Air Fryer S’mores 

Once you’ve mastered the classic recipe for air fryer s’mores, there are plenty of ways to customize them depending on your taste preferences.

For a more decadent treat, try adding peanut butter or hazelnut spread between the marshmallow and chocolate layers before placing them in the air fryer basket.

Or add some crushed nuts or dried fruit for a crunchy texture contrast. The possibilities are endless! 


Air fryer s’mores are a great way to get your s’more fix without having to build a campfire.

And while traditional ingredients like marshmallows and graham crackers work best, there are plenty of tasty substitutions out there so that anyone can enjoy this delicious treat even if they don’t have access to those ingredients at home.

No matter which type or brand of chocolate you choose for your air fryer s’mores, they will turn out delicious every time as long as you use quality ingredients and follow these tips.

Remember that experimentation is key; don’t be afraid to try new flavors and combinations until you create something truly unique that’s perfect for your taste buds!

With a little practice (and lots of eating!), you’ll soon be an expert at making the perfect air fryer s’more every time!

Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.

Kapnos Taverna Author - Small
About the author

Natalie is a food enthusiast who spends all of her time trying out new recipes, testing out new appliances, and making her kitchen as awesome as possible. She is a professional writer and blogs here about her love of food & kitchen.

Leave a Comment